0844 249 3844

Please note that calls to numbers pre-fixed 0844 are not free*

N.B. calls to numbers pre-fixed 0844 are not free*

Let's Combat the Culture of Fraud, but Retain Justice

Posted 11 November 2016 by Donna Scully

Let’s Combat the Culture of Fraud, but Retain Justice

Winter is coming. I’m not referring to the television series Game of Thrones or even the change of seasons. I am talking about my growing sense of foreboding as it becomes clear that the Government’s proposals on personal injury may have been delayed, are not a ministerial priority, but are still very much coming. At an Insurance Times roundtable meeting in September, before the delay, it was clear that the scale of reform being prepared goes well beyond George Osborne’s headline statement last autumn. The Ministry of Justice is still preparing to plot a course that will have far reaching implications for genuine claimants and all those who seek to protect their interests.

Fighting fraud should be the primary goal of the coming reforms, but I fear that it has morphed into something far more ambitious in scope, certainly more pervading, and in my view, deeply troubling with an uncertain outcome. The reform programme will likely seek to end and prevent compensatory claims across the board for so called ‘lower value’ and ‘non-serious injury claims’. Hurrah many of you will shout. The end of the compensation culture. The end of unnecessary claims. A dramatic reduction in costs.

The lessons of the past have clearly not been learnt and appear to be in danger of being repeated. LASPO was supposed to tackle the so-called compensation culture. The early operation of MedCo has been beset by problems. Both were rushed, ill-thought out and the unintended consequences were ignored. Reforms that fail to actively engage with all sides of the sector have a history of not achieving what they set out to achieve. The ABI, IFB, MIB, FOIL and the regulators are undoubtedly key players in solving some of the problems in the sector, but what about claimant lawyers, who deal with some of the problems day-in and day-out. There are undoubtedly some bad lawyers, but they are most definitely a minority, and should not be considered the norm.

The Department of Transport estimates that around 710,000 people are injured to some degree in RTAs each year. That is a lot of customers who currently expect their motor insurance to cover them for just such accidents. Under the prevailing wind of change, a large percentage of these will be told ‘no’, you are not entitled to the cover and compensation that you expected. I fear they will feel very let down by us and the system.

There is always scope for sharing data and intelligence better, improving MedCo and a host of other practical measures. Instead, we are in danger of opening the industry to the worst excesses of a US-style market and a range of other consequences. We need genuine discussion and consideration of the impacts of these proposals, not a two-dimensional consultation about a set of measures that have already been decided. For an insurance market that needs predictability and limiting uncertainty, I cannot think of a worse course of action.

It must be right that the ideal outcome of any reforms is less fraud, less cost, protection

Donna Scully



© 2017 Carpenters. All rights reserved.
Directors: John Carpenter, Donna Scully


Carpenters is authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority under number 625845 www.sra.org.uk
and is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority under number 755996 www.fca.org.uk

*Please note that calls to numbers pre-fixed 0844 are not free - for BT residential customers the cost is no more than 7p per minute plus a 15.97p set-up fee (@June 2015). The cost for non-BT phone lines may be different. Please check the BT price list for charges to other 0844 numbers as charges vary depending on the three digits following 0844. Calls to 0800, 0808 and 0500 numbers are free if made from a UK landline. Non-BT customers and mobile phone users should contact their service providers for information about the cost of calls.