0844 249 3844

Please note that calls to numbers pre-fixed 0844 are not free*

N.B. calls to numbers pre-fixed 0844 are not free*

The CMC Review - No Silver Bullet

Posted 13 June 2016 by Donna Scully

Be bold and brave. You won’t find this in the official terms of reference. But this was the brief given to Carol Brady on her appointment to conduct a ‘fundamental review’ of the Claims Management Company (CMC) sector announced in the July 2015 Budget statement.

At a recent Insurance Times Fraud Charter meeting, Carol spoke frankly about her review and its findings. After several months of investigation, she concluded that the answer wasn’t to simply close the sector down. Although finding a lot of bad firms, she thought that when CMCs were good, they played a vital role in helping people gain access to justice. It wasn’t necessary to throw the baby out with the bathwater; the regulator already had some good tools available, but a new toolkit could be developed for the future regulator.

Although a non-executive member of the Ministry of Justice’s (MoJ) Claims Management Regulation Unit since July 2014, she decided that future regulation of the sector should sit with the FCA, whose screening mechanisms should ensure the necessary high bar to entry. She wants to see a tough licensing regime, accountability, good record keeping and an audit trail, including copies of all telephone calls, for at least 12 months. She, like us all, wants to see more control of cold calling and more transparency around opting in/out. Other regulators, such as the Solicitors Regulation Authority, should be doing more too.

Carol also talked about how we as an industry can improve. She would like to see insurers paying out less quickly and challenge more cases to send a clear message to those considering abusing the system. She also wants to see the end of ‘pre-meds’.

I would have liked to see her review go much further in standing up against the many CMCs intent on exploiting customers and insurers. I certainly hope that we see a rigorous and robust regulatory regime from the FCA once it takes over responsibility. To do that it will require sufficient funding and resources to deliver positive change.

The regulation of CMCs is never going to be a silver bullet, but one element of a package of reforms to properly overhaul the claims system for the benefit of genuine insurance customers. We have come far in reforming the system – the MoJ Portal, fixed costs, AskCUEPI, MedCo, the Insurance Fraud Taskforce and the CMC review. But we are at a tipping point. The next round of proposed measures will undoubtedly impact negatively on many innocent motor insurance customers, the very people that insurance is supposed to help. We must preserve a system where genuine customers are treated fairly and decently. Now that would be bold and brave.

Donna Scully, Carpenters



© 2017 Carpenters. All rights reserved.
Directors: John Carpenter, Donna Scully


Carpenters is authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority under number 625845 www.sra.org.uk
and is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority under number 755996 www.fca.org.uk

*Please note that calls to numbers pre-fixed 0844 are not free - for BT residential customers the cost is no more than 7p per minute plus a 15.97p set-up fee (@June 2015). The cost for non-BT phone lines may be different. Please check the BT price list for charges to other 0844 numbers as charges vary depending on the three digits following 0844. Calls to 0800, 0808 and 0500 numbers are free if made from a UK landline. Non-BT customers and mobile phone users should contact their service providers for information about the cost of calls.